Good try, needs fixing

The game implementation is decent, but the "Create Account" feature doesn't work. Also, when I quit a match, there's some partial info up the right-hand side of the screen that looks like it might be a game log of some sort, but there isn't enough to read. That goes away after a few taps on other buttons. Also not happy that I have paid $4 for the basic game, but that any variety of chips seems to require that I spend more. There's no apparent way to unlock characters or other chips.

Great Implementation

I've played Puzzel Strike off and on for a couple of years. I have the board game version, and I used to play the Free Web Version while I was on my walking treadmill. This iOS implementation is very polished. I was a little worried after readinng the negitive reviews, but I went forward with a buddy and we both bought a copy. It played smooth as single player (and the puzzle mode is nice), and today we tried it multiplayer. At first we could not get a custom game started (we'd pick the characters but could not start it or edit the bank), so I posted on the Forum on their website, and within 5 mins (9pm cst) there was a reply from the admin stating the Server was in a "bad state" for iOS and he'd reboot it. Well he did, and my friend and I did about 4 hours of stable play across the internet (while running Facetime). Super solid implementation - though with hiccups and growing pains.

Great game, no users

Puzzle Strike is a phenomenal game for the right players. It's Deck building (like Dominion) with a high degree of counter-play that makes games between experienced players a joy. A good match of Puzzle Strike is more satisfying than Dominion or Hearthstone because the role of luck is secondary to strategic choices, and different characters mixed with the random stacks of chips allow for a high degree of variation. The game's competitive core isn't for everyone, so while I love the physical board game version, it doesn't get a lot of play in my circles. Some had hoped this version would solve the matchmaking problem and let me enjoy the game more often. Alas, there are not enough players to find a game in a reasonable amount of time, and certainly not enough players for organized ranked play, at least not on the timeframe steam and mobile gamers expect. I bought the game and unlocks all the options at launch, was pleased with the port and usability on my iPad mini. Unfortunately the number of online players was always single digit,and it looks worse now. I think Sirlin made a big mistake not offering the base set for free. A free base would make it hugely more likely that players can find an opponent. Free players increase the quality of the experience for paying players. I don't know if Sirlin made the choice on principal or because as a small dev his team wasn't ready for that many players, but the choice has all but killed this app. The sad reality is that this app has made me less interested in future work from a designer I hugely admire.

Not ready for prime time.

As mentioned by others, the create account system just doesn't work. And there's no way to contact the developers to alert them to the problem. Which means I won't be spending the $12(!!!!) to unlock the rest of he game. Which, by the way, feels a bit exorbitant for an app that doesn't support pass and play, and since I can't log in, means I can't play with my friends at all. See, if you do the math, $12 * 4 means that you and your friends will pay $48 to play the full game against each other. That's more than the cost of the actual board game.

Too expensive

This is a Free to play game that costs you $4 (thus not free at all). It comes only with four characters out of like 30ish and you can’t unlock them at all except through ANOTHER $12 in app purchase. Nothing to unlock them in game. The pricing is nothing near online with other games. The gameplay itself only merited the extra star I gave because the board game is fun. Until they give you all the characters for maybe a $5 purchase... just pass and spend your money on a better and complete game.

Broken

Messages that display programmer info (like an empty object showing as "{0}")' no Undo for many actions, and a Custom game mode that doesn't let you choose your bank or start the game. This feels like a Single Player beta. It is in no way finished and doesn't merit the $4 price tag. Keep your money until Sirlin gets their act together.

No pass and play?

Seems like a good implementation, but no pass and play, an option almost every board game app has, ruins it for me. If I had known this common feature was missing I would not have bought it. Game is great, I own the physical copy.

Great game left to collect dust

Sirlin has a disappointing habit of creating great games like puzzle strike and codex and then not putting in the effort to maintain them.

The iOS version of Sirlin Games' Puzzle Strike is a tricky game to review.

TouchArcade Sat Sep 30 2017

Last year I reviewed a unique deck-building game, Puzzle Strike, which uses cardboard poker chips instead of cards.

WIRED Mon Sep 30 2013

The higher your gem pile, the more powerful you become—but if they get too high, you'll be overwhelmed!

GeekDad Wed Aug 30 2023

While eyes are Street Fighter V, we're going to bring up one of Ryu and Ken's more divergent appearances. Puzzle Fighter HD, which featured...

Game Informer Sun Jul 30 2017

Fantasy Strike has been available to play since 2017 in Steam Early Access, but we now know when it'll be making it's debut on consoles with...

EventHubs Sat Jan 30 2021

Card game designer David Sirlin (Yomi, Puzzle Strike) has announced plans to release a new card game inspired by real-time-strategy computer...

ICv2 Sat Sep 30 2017

Puzzle Strike is a very cool deck-building game that uses bags of chips instead of decks of cards. But what really sets it apart isn't so...

WIRED Mon Jun 30 2014

Sirlin Games is known for its series of games set in the Fantasy Strike universe, in which many colorful characters take part in a Street...

GeekDad Sat May 30 2015

Sirlin Games, the studio, or rather, the developer behind titles like Fantasy Strike and Puzzle Strike, is currently developing their...

Android Gram Tue Sep 16 2025